Trump’s special envoy criticizes Hamas for ‘impractical’ demands in hostage negotiations
Steve Witkoff, former special envoy to the Middle East under President Trump, slammed Hamas for its "impractical" demands in the Gaza conflict, hindering hostage negotiations and worsening the humanitarian crisis.
Steve Witkoff, President Donald Trump’s special envoy to the Middle East, has condemned Hamas for its "impractical" demands amid ongoing tensions in the Gaza conflict. His statement came as Hamas rejected calls for a ceasefire extension and refused to immediately release Edan Alexander, a hostage caught in the crossfire of the war. Hamas’s stance in the ongoing negotiations has drawn sharp criticism, with Witkoff emphasizing that such demands not only hinder peace talks but also prolong the suffering of civilians. This setback has sparked further international concern regarding the hostages’ fate.
Trump's Middle East envoy Witkoff says Hamas 'impractical' in Gaza ceasefire talks. Photo: Middle East Eye.
Growing tensions: Hamas and hostage negotiations
The situation in Gaza continues to deteriorate as Hamas’s refusal to negotiate in good faith has exacerbated the crisis. Witkoff's statement underscores the urgency of addressing humanitarian needs while condemning the extremist group's approach to the hostage situation. The proposal called for Hamas to release living hostages in exchange for prisoners in accordance with previous formulas, according to Witkoff.
The ceasefire would be extended to resume significant humanitarian assistance, he said. Through Qatari and Egyptian partners, Hamas was told in no uncertain terms that this “bridge” would have to be implemented soon, and that Alexander, a dual U.S.-Israel citizen, would have to be released immediately, Witkoff said.
The importance of ceasefire extensions
A ceasefire extension was widely regarded as essential for securing the release of hostages and preventing further bloodshed. However, Hamas’s demands have been labeled as unrealistic, with the group allegedly using the hostages as leverage to gain political advantage. “President Trump has made it clear that Hamas will either release hostages immediately, or pay a severe price,” Witkoff said.
“Unfortunately, Hamas has chosen to respond by publicly claiming flexibility while privately making demands that are entirely impractical without a permanent ceasefire,” Witkoff said. “Hamas is making a very bad bet that time is on its side. It is not. Hamas is well aware of the deadline, and should know that we will answer accordingly if that deadline passes.”