Kim Kardashian faces lawsuit after misidentifying New York man in death row advocacy post
Kim Kardashian is facing a defamation lawsuit after mistakenly using a New York man's photo in an Instagram post advocating for a Texas death row inmate with the same name, leading to claims of reputational damage and emotional distress.
In a recent legal development, reality TV star and criminal justice reform advocate, Kim Kardashian, is being sued for defamation by Ivan A. Cantu, a project manager from Westchester, New York. The lawsuit stems from a February 2024 incident in which Kardashian mistakenly used Cantu's photograph in an Instagram post intended to halt the execution of a Texas death row inmate with the same name. This error has allegedly subjected the New York resident to public ridicule and emotional distress.
Kardashian, known for her efforts in criminal justice reform, shared the post with her 350 million Instagram followers, urging them to sign a petition to prevent the execution of Ivan Cantu, who was convicted of a double homicide in Texas. Unfortunately, instead of featuring the inmate's image, the post displayed a photo of the New York-based Ivan A. Cantu. Despite promptly removing the incorrect image upon realizing the mistake, the damage had already been done.
Kim Kardashian mistakenly IDs NYC project manager as death row inmate on Instagram. Photo: Page Six Composition.
Legal implications of the misidentification
The lawsuit, filed in Los Angeles Superior Court, accuses Kardashian of libel, slander and negligence. Ivan A. Cantu claims that the erroneous post has led to significant harm to his reputation, causing him emotional and psychological trauma. His attorney emphasized the profound impact of the incident, stating that Cantu has endured "emotional distress and anxiety" as a result of being falsely portrayed as a convicted murderer.
Kardashian's legal representative described the incident as a "simple mistake" made during her advocacy efforts. He noted that the image was removed almost immediately after the error was discovered and expressed a preference to resolve the matter amicably without litigation. However, Cantu's legal team contends that attempts to contact Kardashian's representatives prior to filing the lawsuit were unsuccessful.
The execution of the Texas inmate
The intended subject of Kardashian's post, Ivan Abner Cantu, was executed on February 28, 2024, for the 2001 murders of his cousin, James Mosqueda, and Mosqueda's fiancée, Amy Kitchen. Despite maintaining his innocence and receiving support from various public figures and organizations, including Kardashian, the execution proceeded as scheduled.
This incident underscores the significant influence wielded by public figures on social media platforms and the potential consequences of misinformation. While Kardashian's advocacy for criminal justice reform has been widely recognized, this situation highlights the necessity for meticulous verification of information before sharing it with a vast audience. The lawsuit serves as a reminder of the legal and ethical responsibilities that accompany a substantial social media presence.